Arthroscopy: The Journal of Arthroscopic and Related Surgery
Volume 21, Issue 6 , Pages 652-658 , June 2005

Arthroscopic Versus Open Repair for Traumatic Anterior Shoulder Instability: A Meta-analysis

  • Nicholas G.H. Mohtadi, M.D. (F.R.C.S.C.)

      Affiliations

    • University of Calgary Sport Medicine Centre, Calgary, Alberta, Canada
    • Corresponding Author InformationAddress correspondence and reprint requests to Nicholas G. H. Mohtadi, M.D., F.R.C.S.C., University of Calgary Sport Medicine Centre, 2500 University Dr N.W., Calgary, Alberta T2N 1N4, Canada.
    • ,
  • Ivan J. Bitar, M.D.

      Affiliations

    • Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Sanatorio Allende, Córdoba, Argentina
    • ,
  • Treny M. Sasyniuk, B.P.E.

      Affiliations

    • University of Calgary Sport Medicine Centre, Calgary, Alberta, Canada
    • ,
  • Robert M. Hollinshead, M.D. (F.R.C.S.C.)

      Affiliations

    • University of Calgary Sport Medicine Centre, Calgary, Alberta, Canada
    • ,
  • Wade P. Harper, M.B.B.S. (F.R.A.C.S.(Orth))

      Affiliations

    • Prince of Wales Hospital, Sydney, Australia.

References 

  1. Bankart A . Recurrent or habitual dislocation of the shoulder Joint . BMJ . 1923;2:1132–1133
  2. Bankart A . The pathology and treatment of recurrent dislocation of the shoulder joint . Br J Surg . 1938;26:23–29
  3. Dickson J , Devas M . Bankart’s operation for recurrent dislocation of the shoulder . J Bone Joint Surg Br . 1957;39:114–119
  4. Bigliani L , Kurzweil P , Schwartzbach C , et al.   Inferior capsular shift procedure for anterior-inferior shoulder instability in athletes . Am J Sports Med . 1994;10:187–197
  5. Rowe C , Patel D , Southmayd W . The Bankart procedure (A long-term end result study) . J Bone Joint Surg Am . 1978;60:1–16
  6. Weaver JK , Derkash RS . Don’t forget the Bristow-Latarjet procedure . Clin Orthop . 1994;308:102–110
  7. Braly WG , Tullos HS . A modification of the Bristow procedure for recurrent anterior shoulder dislocation and subluxation . Am J Sports Med . 1985;13:81–86
  8. Head SR , Grimberg B , Chesar J , Soudry M . [Magnuson-Stack operation for chronic anterior shoulder instability.] . Harefuah . 1996;130:300–304 358 Hebrew
  9. Regan WD , Webster-Bogaert S , Hawkins RJ , Fowler PJ . Comparative functional analysis of the Bristow, Magnuson-Stack, and Putti-Platt procedures for recurrent dislocation of the shoulder . Am J Sports Med . 1989;17:42–48
  10. Karlsson J , Jarvholm U , Sward L , Lansing O . Repair of Bankart lesions with a suture anchor in recurrent dislocation of the shoulder . Scand J Med Sci Sports . 1995;5:170–174
  11. Levine W , Richmond J , Donaldson W . Use of suture anchor in open Bankart reconstruction (A follow-up report) . Am J Sports Med . 1994;22:723–726
  12. Morrey BF , Janes JM . Recurrent anterior dislocation of the shoulder. Long-term follow-up of the Putti-Platt and Bankart procedures . J Bone Joint Surg Am . 1976;58:252–256
  13. Rao JP , Francis AM , Hurley J , Daczkewycz R . Treatment of recurrent anterior dislocation of the shoulder by duToit Staple capsulorrhaphy. Results of long-term follow-up study . Clin Orthop . 1986;204:169–176
  14. Baker C , Uribe JW , Whitman C . Arthroscopic evaluation of acute initial anterior shoulder dislocations . Am J Sport Med . 1990;18:25–28
  15. Hinterman B , Gachter A . Arthroscopic findings after shoulder dislocation . Am J Sports Med . 1996;23:545–551
  16. Norlin R . Intraarticular pathology in acute, first-time anterior shoulder dislocation. An arthroscopic study . Arthroscopy . 1993;9:546–549
  17. Taylor DC , Arciero RA . Pathologic changes associated with shoulder dislocations. Arthroscopic and physical examination findings in first-time, traumatic anterior dislocations . Am J Sports Med . 1997;25:306–311
  18. Speer K , Warren R , Pagnani M . An arthroscopic technique for anterior stabilization of the shoulder with a bioabsorbable tack . J Bone Joint Surg Am . 1996;78:1801–1807
  19. Arciero R , Wheeler J , Ryan J , McBride J . Arthroscopic Bankart repair versus nonoperative treatment for acute initial anterior shoulder dislocations . Am J Sports Med . 1994;22:589–594
  20. Caspari R . Arthroscopic reconstruction for anterior shoulder instability . Tech Orthop . 1998;3:59–66
  21. Bacilla P , Field L , Savoie F . Arthroscopic Bankart repair in a high demand patient population . Arthroscopy . 1997;13:51–60
  22. Benedetto K , Glotzer W . Arthroscopic Bankart procedure by suture technique (Indication, techniques, and results) . Arthroscopy . 1992;8:111–115
  23. Belzer J , Synder J . Arthroscopic capsulorrhaphy for traumatic anterior shoulder instability using suture anchors and nonabsorbable suture . Arthroscopy . 1995;11:359
  24. Coughlin L , Rubinovich M , Johansson J , White B , Greenspoon J . Arthroscopic staple capsulorrhaphy for anterior shoulder instability . Am J Sports Med . 1992;20:253–256
  25. Fealy S , Drakos MC , Allen AA , Warren RF . Arthroscopic Bankart repair (Experience with an absorbable, transfixing implant) . Clin Orthop . 2001;390:31–41
  26. Goldberg BJ , Nirschl RP , McConnell JP , Pettrone FA . Arthroscopic transglenoid suture capsulolabral repairs (Preliminary results) . Am J Sports Med . 1993;21:656–665
  27. Grana W , Buckley P , Yates C . Arthroscopic Bankart suture repair . Am J Sports Med . 1993;21:348–353
  28. Hawkins R . Arthroscopic stapling repair for shoulder instability (A retrospective study of 50 cases) . Arthroscopy . 1989;5:122–128
  29. Hoffman F , Reif G . Arthroscopic shoulder stabilization using Mitek anchors . Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc . 1995;3:50–54
  30. Kirkley A , Griffin S , Richards C , Miniaci A , Mohtadi N . Prospective randomized clinical trial comparing the effectiveness of immediate arthroscopic stabilization versus immobilization and rehabilitation in first traumatic anterior dislocations of the shoulder . Arthroscopy . 1999;15:507–514
  31. Landsiedl F . Arthroscopic therapy of recurrent anterior luxation of the shoulder by capsular repair . Arthroscopy . 1992;8:269–304
  32. Lane JG , Sachs RA , Riehl B . Arthroscopic staple capsulorrhaphy (A long-term follow-up) . Arthroscopy . 1993;9:190–194
  33. Lauencin C , Stephens S , Warren R . Arthroscopic Bankart repair using a degradable tack . Clin Orthop . 1996;332:132–137
  34. Marcacci M , Zaffagnini S , Petitto A . Arthroscopic management of recurrent anterior dislocation of the shoulder (Analysis of technical modifications on the Caspari procedure) . Arthroscopy . 1996;12:144–149
  35. Matthews L , Vetter W , Oweida S . Arthroscopic staple capsulorrhaphy for recurrent anterior shoulder instability . Arthroscopy . 1988;4:106–111
  36. Morgan C , Bodenstab A . Arthroscopic Bankart suture repair. Technique and early results . Arthroscopy . 1987;3:111–112
  37. Pagnani M , Warren R , Altchek D . Arthroscopic shoulder stabilization using transglenoid sutures (A four year minimum follow-up) . Am J Sports Med . 1996;24:459–467
  38. Post WR . Percutaneous tensioning of the glenohumeral ligaments during arthroscopic Bankart repair . Arthroscopy . 1996;12:116–119
  39. Resch H , Wykypiel HF , Maurer H , Wambacher M . The antero-inferior (transmuscular) approach for arthroscopic repair of the Bankart lesion (An anatomic and clinical study) . Arthros-copy . 1996;12:309–322
  40. Resch H . [Current aspects in the arthroscopic treatment of shoulder instability.] . Orthopade . 1991;20:273–281 German
  41. Resch H , Povacz P , Wambacher M , Sperner G , Golser K . Arthroscopic extra-articular Bankart repair for the treatment of recurrent anterior shoulder dislocation . Arthroscopy . 1997;13:188–200
  42. Rose DJ . Arthroscopic transglenoid suture capsulorrhaphy for anterior shoulder instability . Instr Course Lect . 1996;45:57–64
  43. Speer K , Warren R . Arthroscopic shoulder stabilization (A role of biodegradable materials) . Clin Orthop . 1993;291:67–74
  44. Walch G , Boileau P , Levigne C . Arthroscopic stabilization for recurrent anterior shoulder dislocation (Result of 59 cases) . Arthroscopy . 1995;11:173–179
  45. Warner J , Deng X , Warren R . Arthroscopic Bankart repair utilizing a cannulated absorbable fixation device . Orthop Trans . 1991;14:761–762
  46. Youssef JA , Carr CF , Walther CE , Murphy JM . Arthroscopic Bankart suture repair for recurrent traumatic unidirectional anterior shoulder dislocations . Arthroscopy . 1995;11:561–563
  47. Cole BJ , Warner JJ . Arthroscopic versus open Bankart repair for traumatic anterior shoulder instability . Clin Sports Med . 2000;19:19–48
  48. Cole BJ , L’Insalata J , Irrgang J , Warner JJ . Comparison of arthroscopic and open anterior shoulder stabilization. A two to six-year follow-up study . J Bone Joint Surg Am . 2000;82:1108–1114
  49. Green M , Christensen K . Magnetic resonance imaging of the glenoid labrum (MR imaging of 88 arthroscopically confirmed cases) . Am J Sports Med . 1994;22:493–498
  50. Guanche C , Quick D , Sodergen K . Arthroscopic versus open reconstruction of the shoulder with isolated Bankart lesions . Am J Sports Med . 1996;24:144–148
  51. Geiger D , Hurley J , Tovey J , Rao J . Results of arthroscopic versus open Bankart suture repair . Clin Orthop Rel Res . 1997;337:111–117
  52. Field L , Savoie F , Griffith P . A comparison of open and arthroscopic Bankart repair . J Shoulder Elbow Surg . 1999;8:195; (abstr)
  53. Steinbeck J , Jerosch J . Arthroscopic transglenoid stabilization versus open anchor suturing in traumatic anterior instability of the shoulder . Am J Sports Med . 1998;26:373–378
  54. Meeuwisee W . Interpretation of research—KNES 490. Chap 5 . Calgary, AB, Canada: University of Calgary; 1998–99;
  55. Canadian Task Force on the Periodic Health Examination . Recommendations by strength of evidence clinical preventative health care . Ottawa, ON, Canada: Canada Communication Group; 1994; vii-xxxvii
  56. Kim SH , Ha KI . Bankart repair in traumatic anterior shoulder instability (Open versus arthroscopic technique) . Arthroscopy . 2002;18:755–763
  57. Karlsson J , Magnusson L , Ejerhed L , Hultenheim I , Lundin O , Kartus J . Comparison of open and arthroscopic stabilization for recurrent shoulder dislocation in patients with a Bankart lesion . Am J Sports Med . 2001;29:538–542
  58. Roberts S , Taylor D , Brown J , Hayes M , Saies A . Open and arthroscopic techniques for the treatment of traumatic anterior shoulder instability in Australian rules football players . J Shoulder Elbow Surg . 1999;8:403–409
  59. Sperber A , Hamberg P , Karlsson J , Sward L , Wredmark T . Comparison of an arthroscopic and an open procedure for posttraumatic instability of the shoulder (A prospective, randomized multicenter study) . J Shoulder Elbow Surg . 2001;10:105–108
  60. Jorgensen U , Svend-Hansen H , Bak K , Pedersen I . Recurrent post-traumatic anterior shoulder dislocation—open versus arthroscopic repair . Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc . 1999;7:118–124
  61. Kartus J , Ejerhed L , Funck E , Kohler K , Sernert N , Karlsson J . Arthroscopic and open shoulder stabilization using absorbable implants. A clinical and radiographic comparison of two methods . Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc . 1998;6:181–188
  62. Weber S . A prospective evaluation comparing arthroscopic and open treatment in the management of recurrent anterior glenohumeral dislocation . Orthop Trans . 1991;15:763

PII: S0749-8063(05)00274-4

doi: 10.1016/j.arthro.2005.02.021

Arthroscopy: The Journal of Arthroscopic and Related Surgery
Volume 21, Issue 6 , Pages 652-658 , June 2005

Article Tools

* Image Usage & Resolution