Hip arthroscopy is not easy. Improving access for hip arthroscopy is as easy as pie (-crusting). But is it better? The hip is a tight, deep joint. The skin incisions are farther away from the joint than those in knee, shoulder or elbow arthroscopy. Any technique that can make this procedure easier and less traumatic for the patient is enticing. “Pie-Crusting Capsulotomy Provides Similar Visualization with Increased Repair Stiffness Compared to a T-Capsulotomy: A Biomechanical Study“
Wydra FB, Al’Khafaji I, Haruno L, et al. Pie-crusting capsulotomy provides similar visualization with increased repair stiffness compared with a T-capsulotomy: A biomechanical study. Arthroscopy 2021;37:2832-2837.
by Wydra, Al’Khafaji, Haruno, Chahla, Nelson, Gerhardt, and Metzger describes a procedure that can make visualization in cam-type femoroacetabular impingement (FAI) simpler and easier.
I must admit that upon reading of this technique, I had a visceral negative reaction. Radiofrequency to the capsule? No thank you. We went down that road with shoulder thermal capsulorrhaphy. Initially, there was great enthusiasm for thermal capsulorraphy,
- Levitz C.L.
- Dugas J.
- Andrews J.R.
The use of arthroscopic thermal caspulorraphy to treat internal impingement in baseball players.
but it quickly curdled when chondrolysis was identified as a complication.
- Good C.R.
- Shindle M.K.
- Kelly B.K.
- Wanich T.
- Warren R.F.
Glenohumeral chondrolysis after shoulder arthroscopy with thermal capsulorraphy.
However, I fought through my initial bias. I recently advocated not
equating the hip joint with the shoulder joint,
Suture anchor fixation eliminates the wave sign and improves outcomes for hip labrochondral dysfunction: Do not equate hip labral pathology with shoulder labral tears.
and my gut reaction was doing just that. (I hate hypocrisy, especially in myself!) I thought and pondered more. The hip joint capsule is thicker than the shoulder,
- Weber A.E.
- Kuhns B.D.
- Cvetanovich G.L.
- Mather R.C.
- Salata M.J.
- Nho S.J.
Does the hip capsule remain closed after hip arthroscopy with routine capsular closure for femoroacetabular impingement? A magnetic resonance imaging analysis in symptomatic postoperative patients.
- Ciccone II, W.J.
- Hunt T.J.
- Lieber R.
- Pedowitz R.
- Esch J.
- Tasto J.P.
Multiquadrant digital analysis of shoulder capsular thickness.
so thermal energy may be less damaging to a hip than to a shoulder. Also, unlike a thermal capsulorraphy, which attempts to “shrink” the capsule, a pie-crusting technique is more limited in scope.
Repairing a capsule after pie-crusting yields similar strength and increased stiffness when compared to a T-capsulotomy, so if a surgeon routinely does a T-capsulotomy, switching to a pie-crusting technique makes sense. However, if surgeon wants to use an intra-articular orthobiologic such as platelet-rich plasma, I would not recommend pie-crusting because the full-thickness slits in the capsule would probably allow the platelet-rich plasma to escape, even after capsular repair.
The extraordinary, recently departed Dr. Howard Sweeney was a mentor of mine.
- Guttmann D.
- Ochiai D.
- Voloshin I.
AANA Traveling Shoulder Fellowship: An Experience of a Lifetime.
As an accomplished surgeon, he had a wealth of expertise and experience, yet he was constantly learning and striving to improve. He was open to new ideas and procedures, and he could analyze them through the lens of his formidable fund of knowledge to form his opinions. Some new procedures are beneficial; some are not. For me, I will still use traction sutures for 100% of my hip arthroscopy procedures. However, in the very rare setting where traction sutures alone yield inadequate exposure, I will perform pie-crusting instead of a T-capsulotomy. I think that is what Dr. Sweeney would have done.
See related article on page 2832
The author reports the following potential conflicts of interest or sources of funding: Full ICMJE author disclosure forms are available for this article online, as supplementary material.
© 2021 by the Arthroscopy Association of North America